Six children, one memo, and the case that hardened into myth
On the morning of February 4, 1987, someone walking through Myers Park in Tallahassee, Florida made a call that would eventually reach the FBI, U.S. Customs, and two members of Congress. What they’d seen was two well-dressed men in suits, standing near a battered blue Dodge van, watching six children who looked like they hadn’t been bathed in days.
The children ranged in age from two to eleven. They were dirty, bug-bitten, and largely nonverbal. Some didn’t seem to recognize a telephone or a staple. Inside the van, police found a mattress, maps, letters, and a smell that suggested all eight of them, two adults, six kids, had been living out of it for some time.
The men were arrested and charged with misdemeanor child abuse. Their explanation, when they gave one, was that they were teachers escorting the children to a special school for gifted children in Mexico, and that the kids were being “weaned from their mothers.” One of the men reportedly dropped face-down on the ground and refused to get up.
Within two days, investigators in Washington, D.C. would raid a house and a warehouse belonging to a secretive group called The Finders and find bags of photographs, a “video room” that looked like an indoctrination center, and files that one Customs agent would later describe, in a memo, as containing instructions for acquiring children. Within a week, a Washington Post headline would use the word “cult.” Within a decade, the case would become one of the founding texts of American conspiracy culture, cited by Satanic Panic researchers, then by Pizzagate believers, then by QAnon.
And yet, in the end, no one was ever charged with a crime involving those children. Not in 1987. Not in the follow-up Justice Department investigation that reopened the case in 1993. The story of The Finders is less a story with an answer than a story about what happens when disturbing evidence, institutional secrecy, and government stonewalling collide, and how quickly that combination hardens into myth.
The group’s founder was a man named Marion David Pettie, born in 1920 near Culpeper, Virginia, to David Clenton Pettie and Virginia Burke. He dropped out of school after ninth grade: “because it was interfering with my education,” he liked to say, and spent much of his adult life in the Air Force, retiring as a master sergeant in 1956. After that, by his own account, he did very little conventional work. Being a cult leader, he sometimes joked, was the job.
He traced the origins of what became The Finders back decades, to two apartments he rented in Washington, D.C. in the 1930s. In later court testimony, he explained his thinking at the time: he opened the apartments up to anyone who wanted to come in, because he believed they would teach him something about “power, money, or sex.” The group as it came to be known coalesced around 1971, when Pettie began gathering followers at his house in the Glover Park neighborhood of D.C. His son George would later call it the beginning of a new life for his father.
Pettie called himself “the Stroller.” Inside the group, he was “the Game Caller”, a title that referred to the central practice around which the entire community was organized.
The Finders weren’t a religious cult in any traditional sense. There was no shared scripture, no single deity, no formal doctrine. What they had instead was an eclectic stew of ideas; pieces of Taoism, New Age philosophy, the Human Potential Movement, and the work of Carlos Castaneda, filtered through Pettie’s personal authority. Cult scholars who later studied the group pointed to “futurism,” broadly defined, as one of its defining threads. Pettie himself, in a rare 1996 interview, described himself as a skeptic who didn’t particularly believe or disbelieve anything.
What held the group together in practice was something members called The Game. Pettie would identify what he saw as a flaw or a lesson a member needed to learn, then send them out on an “adventure” designed to confront it. When they returned, they’d report back on what they’d learned. One former member, a onetime CPA and venture capitalist named Robert “Tobe” Terrell who joined in the early 1970s, described these adventures as deliberately engineered pressure, everything from a temp job at a D.C. law firm to being put on a plane to Japan with two hours’ notice to gather corporate intelligence and report back.
By the 1980s, the group had shifted its aesthetic. Neighbors near the group’s Virginia farm noticed the hippie clothing of the 1970s giving way to business suits. Membership peaked at somewhere around two to three dozen adults, along with roughly a dozen children, split across a handful of properties: a house on W Street NW in Glover Park, where women and children lived; a warehouse on Fourth Street NE, occupied by the men; and a ninety-acre farm near Nethers, Virginia, in the shadow of Old Rag Mountain, which had been hosting counterculture visitors with free organic meals since the late 1960s.
Money moved through the group communally. Terrell called the early version of this arrangement “the Invisible Bank.” Later, Pettie replaced it with something called the Last Man’s Club, money went in, and it didn’t come back out.
Around 1980, the group made a decision that would later become central to the Tallahassee case: they would raise the next generation of children communally, modeled loosely on their own idea of how Native American communities raised children, rather than leaving that job to individual biological parents. The children weren’t enrolled in school. While their parents went off on Game-assigned adventures, the children were cared for collectively by whichever adults were around.
The Finders also ran a handful of legitimate-looking businesses: Global Press, Information Bank, AAA-1 Information Finders, Graphics News Service, Bio World, and Emergency Services among them, with several operating out of the National Press Building in downtown D.C. One of these threads would later become the closest thing to a verifiable government connection the case ever produced: a computer-training firm called Future Enterprises Inc., run by a man named Joseph Marinich, held a contract to train CIA employees on computers and reportedly employed some Finders members. Marinich denied that his company had anything to do with The Finders as an organization.
The two men arrested in Tallahassee were Douglas Ammerman, 27, and a man identified in most reporting as James Michael Holwell, though some records list him as 23, others as 28, and at least one account gives his name as Michael Houlihan. The inconsistencies start early in this case and never fully resolve.
The six children were identified in a later court document by first names only, Honeybee, John Franklin, Bee Bee, Max, and Mary, a list that oddly accounts for only five names among six kids. Police described them as covered in insect bites, unwashed for days, mostly without underwear, and in several cases unable to identify basic household objects. A police spokesman initially said one child, a six-year-old girl, showed signs of sexual abuse, a claim that was never substantiated. A psychiatrist retained by Florida’s Department of Health and Rehabilitative Services later examined the children and found depression, but no signs of recent physical or sexual abuse.
Both men were held on $100,000 bond each. Word of the arrests spread fast enough that Tallahassee police reportedly fielded hundreds of calls from women claiming to be the children’s mothers. The actual mothers, all Finders members, eventually arrived in Tallahassee, and a Leon County court granted them temporary custody by the end of February. Their attorney, Paula Walborsky, offered a line that captured just how far the reality diverged from the rumor that had already started to spread: they didn’t show up in saffron robes smeared in goat blood, she said. They came in tweed and pearls.
Roughly six weeks after the arrests, the state dropped all charges against Ammerman and Holwell. The men were released. On paper, that should have been the end of it.

It wasn’t the end of it, because while the Tallahassee case was unfolding, D.C. police, acting partly on a tip a detective named Jim Bradley had received two months earlier from a source describing “blood rituals” and orgies involving children, searched the group’s W Street house and Fourth Street warehouse, with help from U.S. Customs.
What came out of those buildings was the material that gave the case its lasting, disturbing shape. Officers removed bags of photographs and contact sheets, some depicting naked children. Court documents described what investigators characterized as brainwashing and ritual use of children. Customs officials described photographs of what looked like animal bloodletting ceremonies, and one photo of a child in chains.
The most detailed, and most disputed, account of what was found comes from a single Customs agent, Ramon J. Martinez, whose internal memos described a “computer room” containing documents that appeared to lay out methods for acquiring children, including references to impregnating female members, purchasing and trading children, and even a telex allegedly ordering the purchase of two children in Hong Kong through a contact at the Chinese embassy. Martinez also described files touching on high-tech transfers to the U.K., international currency transfers, terrorism, explosives, and something labeled a Pentagon break-in; a photo album he called “The Execution of Henrietta and Igor,” showing people in white sheets slaughtering goats; a video room set up, in his description, as an indoctrination center; something resembling an altar; and jars of urine and feces.
One of the property owners, Tobe Terrell, pushed back hard on the darkest interpretations. He said the naked-child photos were simply pictures of Holwell’s own children, and that the “bloodletting” images showed goats that had already been butchered and were being prepared as food. “We are rational people,” he said. “Not devil worshipers or child molesters.”
It’s worth pausing on something important here: Martinez’s memo is the single most-quoted source for nearly every lurid detail associated with The Finders, and it is also the most contested. An FBI agent named Athena Varounis, sent to follow up on Martinez’s claims about eighteen days later, reported that the lead D.C. detective who had been present during the search, standing right next to Martinez, did not see the items Martinez described. That contradiction has never been resolved, and it sits at the center of everything that makes this case difficult to pin down.
Tallahassee police had called in Customs in the first place because they suspected child pornography, and Customs had a unit for exactly that. From there, the case moved through a small chain of investigators, a Customs agent in Tallahassee, then a senior agent in Virginia, then Martinez, before the FBI’s Foreign Counterintelligence Division got involved as well.
And then, according to Martinez, it simply stopped. He wrote that an off-the-record source told him in April 1987 that the investigation had become “a CIA internal matter,” that the D.C. police report had been classified secret and made unavailable, that the FBI had withdrawn, and that FBI counterintelligence had specifically instructed D.C. police not to update the FBI’s Washington Field Office. His memo ended flatly: no further information would be available, and no further action would be taken.
There is a persistent error here: the agent’s name was Ramon J. Martinez, not “Ray Rubio,” a name that circulates widely online but doesn’t appear in any reliable documentation of the case. It’s also worth noting that at least two other named investigators, Customs agents Walter Kreitlow and Robert Harrold, are sometimes conflated online as a single person; they were not.
The case might have stayed buried if not for a man named Henry “Skip” Clements, a Florida consultant who came into contact with the Finders story through an unrelated child-abuse case. Clements obtained Martinez’s report and, in October 1993, brought it to two members of Congress, Representative Charlie Rose of North Carolina and Representative Tom Lewis of Florida. Clements alleged that the D.C. warehouse had been a fully equipped pornography production studio, and that the CIA had shut the investigation down because the group had been secretly training intelligence agents.
That meeting was enough to prompt a fresh Justice Department inquiry, running from 1993 into 1995, with the FBI’s Washington Field Office and headquarters both involved. It also prompted a wave of national coverage. The Washington Times ran a story headlined “CIA tied to cult accused of abuse,” reporting that the Justice Department was probing the group’s alleged links to the agency. U.S. News & World Report ran a longer piece under the header “Through a Glass, Very Darkly,” opening with the observation that a case nearly seven years old kept getting curiouser and curiouser. It quoted a Tallahassee investigator’s frustration that D.C. police had “dropped this case… like a hot rock,” and quoted Representative Lewis asking, pointedly, whether the government itself had “turned their backs on these children.”
A single unverified line, quoted secondhand in later years by conspiracy researchers, claimed that the CIA had privately admitted to “owning” The Finders as a front for a domestic computer-training operation that had “gone bad.” That claim does not appear anywhere in the FBI’s later declassified files and should be treated as unconfirmed.
The CIA’s response to all of this was blunt denial. An agency spokesman called the allegations “a non-story” and “a nothing-burger,” attributing the confusion to the group’s tangential relationship with Future Enterprises, the computer-training contractor. Tallahassee’s police chief told the FBI directly, in November 1993, that no outside agency had ever contacted his department in an attempt to influence the original investigation. The renewed FBI inquiry closed in 1995 having found no evidence of criminal activity and no evidence of a cover-up.
What can actually be verified, once you strip away the speculation, is more modest than the legend: Pettie’s late wife, Isabelle, had worked for the CIA in the 1950s and into the 1960s, holding passports for restricted countries. Future Enterprises did have a real contract training CIA staff. Pettie’s son had worked for Air America, a CIA proprietary airline. None of that amounts to evidence that The Finders themselves were a CIA front, and no formal investigation ever concluded that they were. Martinez, the agent behind the most explosive memo, was later disciplined, for an unrelated improper disclosure of case information, receiving a five-day suspension and reassignment.
No one, not Ammerman, not Holwell, not Pettie, not any other member of the group, was ever charged with a crime connected to the children.
The group didn’t survive the fallout intact. Most of the mothers left after what came to be called, informally, “Goatgate,” taking their children with them, several families resettled in Boulder, Colorado, others in Berkeley or Tallahassee itself. In the mid-1990s, nine former members sued the group, seeking their share of an estimated two million dollars in property and cash that had accumulated over the decades. Pettie, in one court appearance, claimed not to know the location of a briefcase holding roughly that amount in land deeds.
Pettie stayed in Culpeper, still calling himself the Stroller, still posting cryptic messages, biblical citations, mostly, on the marquee of a movie theater the group owned downtown. He died on October 24, 2003. After his death, a local developer bought the theater from the group for $300,000; the marquee reportedly read “The Phoenix Riseth.” The Finders, as an organization, appears to have dissolved not long after.
One researcher who spent time investigating the group, Wendell Minnick, summed it up years later in a line that captures the gap between the myth and what he found: The Finders, he said, would love for people to think they were a CIA front, but really, they were just a group of dysfunctional adults working themselves to exhaustion.
None of that skepticism stopped The Finders from becoming a foundational story in American conspiracy culture. Ted Gunderson, a retired FBI field office chief, turned full-time conspiracy researcher, became the case’s most tireless promoter, distributing his own pamphlet on the Customs documents and hosting what became the most widely circulated copy of Martinez’s memos online. He wove The Finders into the broader Satanic Panic narrative of the era, linking it to the Franklin child-abuse scandal in Nebraska and to the McMartin preschool case in California, a connection that, in at least one instance, ran backward: a rumor about tunnels under the McMartin school actually originated in one of Gunderson’s own reports, then got attributed back to the Finders case as if it were independent corroboration. Fritz Springmeier’s writing on Illuminati bloodlines and mind control drew on the same well.
The case went quiet for a while, then came roaring back in October 2019, when the FBI released its full file, 332 pages, by some counts, and reportedly the single most-requested topic in the Bureau’s public records vault. Rather than putting the story to rest, the release handed it to a new generation of conspiracy theorizing. Writers covering the Pizzagate and QAnon movements began pointing to The Finders as a kind of patient zero, the first documented instance of the exact pattern those later movements would obsess over: elite pedophile networks operating with quiet institutional protection. Skeptical researchers who’ve revisited the case since, including a 2023 piece in Skeptical Inquirer, have argued the opposite: that what the Finders case really demonstrates is how a handful of disputed claims, combined with real institutional secrecy and a genuinely disturbing set of photographs, can calcify into an unfalsifiable myth that outlives every actual finding of the case.
Strip away four decades of retelling and what’s left is genuinely strange on its own terms, without embellishment: a communal group built around one man’s authority and a psychological practice designed to break down and rebuild its members’ sense of self; six children found in visibly neglected condition, in the company of two adult men making an implausible story about a school in Mexico; a search that turned up material disturbing enough that even the officers involved couldn’t agree on what they’d actually seen; a jurisdictional handoff that looked, from the outside, exactly like a cover-up, whether or not it was one; and a single agent’s memo that has done more work sustaining a forty-year conspiracy theory than any actual court finding.
The honest ending to this story isn’t a revelation. It’s the fact that nobody, not the reporters who covered it in 1987, not the congressmen who reopened it in 1993, not the FBI when it finally released its files in 2019, has ever been able to say with certainty what The Finders actually were.
The Finders Cult Case: A Sourced Guide to Documents, PDFs, and Records Online
The single most authoritative primary source is the FBI’s 2019 “The Finders” Vault release, a four-part, ~700+ page scanned PDF collection at vault.fbi.gov, the FBI’s most-requested topic, supplemented by the U.S. Customs Service “Report of Investigation” by Special Agent Ramon J. Martinez (Feb–April 1987).
Here are all four parts of the files.
Part One:
Part Two:
Part Three:
Part Four:
A spoken word piece and an art page representing The Finders case. Watch it now:

Centarficus © 2015 by Vennie Kocsis is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. All recommendations are my own.
Support Vennie’s writing with a one-time contribution or establish a monthly donation.
Share this post:
Discover more from Vennie Kocsis
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


You must be logged in to post a comment.