On anomalous experiences, the neuroscience of consciousness, and why nobody has taught us how to sail it
I was a teenager in 1986 driving near Reelfoot Lake when something appeared in the night sky that I have never forgotten. Reelfoot itself is a place that shouldn’t exist; a lake shoved into existence by the New Madrid earthquakes, full of drowned cypress standing up out of the water like the ribs of something that died mid-sentence. What I saw spread across the sky on a lone night and cloaked my body with penetrable light. I have thought about that a lot over the years, the fact that the ground under me was already evidence that the world reorganizes itself sometimes without a warning. And then the light that filled the sky. And then the rest of my life spent carrying it.
That wasn’t the first time reality had come loose for me. As a child in the Alaska wilderness, inside a program that used abuse, fear and isolation as tools of control, I went out of my body more than once. I went to places I have spent decades since trying to define and express without leaning in either direction, and without saying it was only my brain, and without saying it was definitely the others. Both of those sentences feel like a door slamming. Remaining in open curiosity has gifted me the most balance in regard to these anomalous experiences.
Here is what I have come to believe: the next real conversation in the world of anomalous experience is not going to happen in the sky. It’s going to happen in the mind. Not as a debunking, or tired sneer of you imagined it. But as a true consciousness expansion. Because if you actually study what the mind sciences have learned in the last forty plus years about what a human mind can generate, sustain, and remember, you do not come away thinking experiencers are foolish. You come away thinking we have all been standing at the edge of an enormous unmapped continent, arguing about whether the boat is real, while the continent itself sits unvisited.
I want to walk that continent for a while.
What the mind does when the body dies
Start where it is hardest to dismiss: the moment of death.
In 2001, The Lancet published a Dutch cardiologist’s prospective study, meaning the patients were interviewed right after resuscitation, before memory had time to construct anything. Pim van Lommel and his colleagues followed 344 consecutive survivors of cardiac arrest across ten hospitals. Sixty-two of those patients (18%) reported a near-death experience, and 41 of them (12%) described what researchers call a core experience.
Independent prospective studies in the years around it hovered in the same neighborhood: across four studies covering 562 patients, somewhere between 10 and 20% reported an experience of heightened consciousness during a period when the cortex and brainstem had gone quiet. Bruce Greyson at the University of Virginia built the standardized scale that made this measurable in the first place, and his own prospective study of 116 cardiac arrest survivors found 15.5% reporting an NDE (near death experience).
Then it got stranger. Sam Parnia’s AWARE-II study, published in Resuscitation in 2023, ran across 25 hospital sites and did something nobody had done: it put EEG and cerebral oxygenation monitoring directly into CPR, in real time, while people were dying. The finding was that despite severe cerebral ischemia, normal EEG activity (delta, theta, alpha) consistent with consciousness emerged as long as 35 to 60 minutes into CPR. The authors’ conclusion was cautious and enormous at the same time: that consciousness, awareness and cognitive processes may occur during cardiac arrest, and that the emergence of normal EEG may reflect a network-level resumption of cognitive activity, a biomarker of lucidity.
Read that again. A brain with almost no oxygen, in the middle of chest compressions, producing the electrical signature of an organized mind, for up to an hour.
I am not going to tell you that proves a soul. It doesn’t. It proves something better for our purposes: the machinery of experience does not switch off when we assumed it did. The lights are on in a house we had declared condemned and expired.
And there’s a companion phenomenon that I find almost unbearable in its tenderness. Terminal lucidity, now often called paradoxical lucidity, is the sudden return of clear mind in a person with advanced dementia, usually days or hours before death. It got dragged into serious research partly because a psychology student named Alexander Batthyány got a phone call in 2000 about his grandmother, who had vascular dementia and had barely spoken in a year, suddenly being herself, speaking the refined German of his childhood, recalling shared memories, and telling him he had brought joy to their lives. She died a few days later. He started collecting cases.
In 2019 the U.S. National Institute on Aging opened funding specifically for research on lucidity in dementia, and a review in Alzheimer’s & Dementia argued that paradoxical lucidity, if systematically confirmed, challenges current assumptions and points to the possibility of network-level return of cognitive function in severe dementia.
A brain that has been eaten by disease, briefly producing a whole person again. We do not know how. The National Institute on Aging does not know how. That is not a fringe claim; that is an open file at a federal research agency.
I want experiencers to sit with that, because it establishes the ground I’m building on: mainstream science currently cannot account for what minds do at the edges of life and lucidity. Those are the realms where we live.
The world you build every night
We are all, every one of us, world-builders. We do it involuntarily for roughly two hours a night.
For a long time dream research had a fatal flaw: you could only ask people afterward, and after is a different country. Then in 2021 four independent laboratories, in the U.S., Germany, France, and the Netherlands, published a joint paper in Current Biology demonstrating something I still find astonishing. They showed that people asleep and in the middle of a lucid dream can perceive questions from an experimenter and answer them using electrophysiological signals, verified by polysomnography, across 36 individuals.
Dreamers performed veridical perceptual analysis of new information, held information in working memory, computed simple answers, and expressed volitional replies, using distinctive eye movements and facial muscle contractions resulting in 29 correctly answered questions across six individuals. Math problems. Yes-or-no questions. All answered from inside their dream.
The researchers described their own goal in a line I have never been able to shake off: that the experiment was akin to finding a way to talk with an astronaut who is on another world, except the world is entirely fabricated on the basis of memories stored in the brain.
Entirely fabricated. And also, another world. Both are true at once. That sentence is the whole thesis of this essay in miniature.
Anyone who has done serious meditative practice, or what people in our circles call astral travel, knows the territory this opens. Lucid dreaming is not rare in the way the anomalous is rare, about 20% of adults have at least one lucid dream a month, though fewer than 1% can reliably signal from inside one in a lab. What’s telling is that even accomplished lucid dreamers often can’t control the dream, and that dream characters, though generated by the dreaming brain, can act as if they have their own intentions and refuse to go along with the dreamer’s requests.
The figures your own mind makes do not obey you. Sit with that one too. Because a great deal of the argument between experiencers and skeptics assumes that “generated by your mind” means “under your control” and therefore “not really an encounter.” That assumption is false in the laboratory, on video, with electrodes attached.
Leaving the body, on command
The out-of-body experience is treated in our community as either sacred or suspect, depending on who’s talking. The neuroscience is more interesting than either position.
Wilder Penfield, stimulating the cortex of conscious patients back in 1941, got a patient reporting a floating sensation. In 2002, Olaf Blanke and colleagues reported a patient in whom out-of-body experiences were elicited during electrical stimulation of her angular gyrus. Then came the case that gets me: a man with intractable tinnitus who had an electrode implanted over the right temporoparietal junction. It didn’t help his tinnitus. Instead, stimulation repeatedly and consistently produced the perception that he was outside his body. PET scanning during the experience showed activation at the temporoparietal junction, the angular–supramarginal gyrus junction and the superior temporal region on the right, plus the right precuneus and posterior thalamus, and the researchers proposed this as the neural correlate of disembodiment.
So, there is a switch. A small region where the brain assembles the sense of where I am, built out of vision, balance, touch, and body position, and when that assembly fails, you are somewhere else. Later work showed that interfering with the right TPJ (the temporoparietal junction, the spot where the temporal and parietal lobes meet, on the right side of the brain roughly behind and above your ear) using transcranial magnetic stimulation impairs people’s ability to mentally transform their own body position, exactly the operation spontaneous OBE reports describe.
Now here’s the honest fork in the road, and I refuse to pretend it isn’t there. Finding the switch does not tell you what the switch is for. You can read this as the self is a construction and OBEs are a construction glitch, which is the standard reading. You can also read it as there is a mechanism by which awareness relocates, and we have just found the dial. Both readings fit the same data. What is not defensible is pretending the question is closed.
The shadow at the foot of the bed
I want to talk about Shadow People, because this is where the mind sciences have the most to offer us and where our experiencer community is the most resistant to hearing it.
Sleep paralysis is a state in which you wake with your sensory system online and your motor system still locked in REM atonia. I wrote about one of these experiences in this post, Three Black Hats.
Hypnagogic and hypnopompic hallucinations are common during it and frequently involve seeing, hearing, and sensing menacing intruders in the bedroom, an intruder often perceived as a shadowy humanoid figure, with supernatural accounts of this figure common across cultures. Baland Jalal and V.S. Ramachandran proposed that a functional disturbance of the right parietal cortex explains the shadowy nocturnal intruder, arising from disrupted multisensory processing of body and self at the temporoparietal junction, the same neighborhood as the out-of-body work, which is not a coincidence.
Here is the part that matters. The figure is not the same everywhere, and yet it is. In Egypt it is a jinn that appears out of nowhere and can kill its victims; in Italy it is the Pandafeche, an evil witch or vicious cat; in South Africa it is segatelelo, black magic involving dwarflike tokoloshe; in Turkey it is the karabasan. The core experience, a human-like shadowy figure approaching, sitting on the chest, suffocating the sleeper, is reported worldwide regardless of cultural context, which is why researchers understand it as driven by underlying neurobiology, while each culture supplies its own interpretation, and REM mentation gives the hallucination culturally distinctive features.
And the rates move with belief. Sleep paralysis is nearly twice as common in Egypt as in Denmark; Italians who think their episodes may have a supernatural origin are more likely to hallucinate during them, including sensing a ghostly presence. Fear predisposes you: when people in these cultures go to bed afraid the cultural creature will attack, that fear fuels the brain’s fear centers, making them more likely to wake during REM, and once in it, they interpret it through their beliefs, which makes them more frightened still. Sleepers in Cairo turned out to be three times more likely than those in Copenhagen to experience it at all.
I know what that sounds like to an experiencer. It sounds like so it’s nothing. It is not nothing. Read it again with different eyes: belief measurably alters the frequency, duration, and content of an experience that has a stable biological core. Your expectations are not decoration on the experience. They are an input. They are a variable in the equation.
This is, incidentally, exactly what the folklorist David Hufford argued decades ago in The Terror That Comes in the Night: the experience comes first, and the supernatural interpretation is built on top of a real, stable, cross-cultural perceptual event, not the other way around. That framework, called the experiential source hypothesis, is one of the most experiencer-respecting ideas ever produced by an academic, and almost nobody in our community has read it.
The person who sees a shadow figure repeatedly is not lying and is not stupid. They are having a real event with a describable neurology, and what they do with it, the frame they hand it, the fear they bring to it, and the meaning they let it carry, is participating in what the event becomes. That is not a smaller story. That is a much bigger one.
Minds that are simply built differently
We talk about experiencers as if we are all running the same hardware. We are not, and the range is wider than most people know.
In 2015, the neurologist Adam Zeman identified something that had gone unidentified for a century: aphantasia, the absence of a mind’s eye, the inability to visualize mental images. And its opposite, hyperphantasia, imagery as vivid as seeing. Around 1% of the population has extreme aphantasia and around 3% extreme hyperphantasia; a large multinational study of over 9,000 people put the figures at roughly 0.9% aphantasia and 6.1% hyperphantasia.
Since coining the terms, Zeman’s group has been contacted by more than 14,000 members of the public with extreme imagery. And these are not trivial differences: people with hyperphantasia outperform controls on autobiographical memory and imagination, controls outperform aphantasics, and resting-state fMRI shows stronger connectivity between prefrontal cortex and the visual network in hyperphantasics.
Some of the people in our communities are running mental imagery indistinguishable from perception. Not metaphorically. Neurologically. And nobody has ever asked them, and they have asked nobody.
Then there is a form of epilepsy called ecstatic epilepsy; a rare focal epilepsy in which the seizure begins with an ecstatic or mystical experience, heightened self-awareness, mental clarity, and a sense of “unity with everything that exists,” with bliss and physical wellbeing. Dostoevsky described his own. Fabienne Picard and colleagues traced it to the dorsal anterior insula and reproduced the ecstatic aura in patients by directly stimulating that region. Their explanation is the piece I want you to hold onto: the state arises from suppression of the interoceptive prediction errors and surprise signals the anterior insula normally processes, mimicking a perfect prediction of the world, and inducing a feeling of certainty. Patients report time dilation, an “eternal now,” external perceptions experienced with acute vividness, and some describe it as life-changing, one no longer feared death.
Certainty is a state the brain can produce. Not a conclusion you reach. A state, with an address, that can be switched on with an electrode.
I am not saying your conviction is a seizure. I am saying that the feeling of absolute rightness that accompanies profound experience, the righteous conviction people carry out of contact, out of NDEs, out of memories of other worlds, is itself a neurological event with its own machinery, and that the presence of overwhelming certainty is not, by itself, evidence about the external world. It is evidence about the depth of the experience. Those are different claims, and conflating them is how our community loses arguments it should be winning.
And then there is culture, doing its quiet work on the content of experience. Tanya Luhrmann, an anthropologist at Stanford, interviewed people with psychosis in San Mateo, Chennai, and Accra. Participants in the USA were more likely to use diagnostic labels and to report violent commands, while those in India and Ghana were more likely to report rich relationships with their voices. Among the Chennai group, more than half heard voices of kin giving instructions like elders advising the young; several heard the voices as playful, as spirits, even as entertaining; in Accra, where the culture accepts that disembodied spirits can speak, few described the voices in brain-disease terms. The Americans, Luhrmann said, felt assaulted by voices full of violence telling them they were worthless and should die. Her explanation for the difference is a sentence that should be tattooed on the inside of every skeptic’s wrist: Americans think of their minds as a private fortress.
Same phenomenon. Different frame. Radically different suffering.
Chemical doors and the entity problem
We should talk about DMT, because it is the cleanest available demonstration that the mind, given the right key, will reliably open a door onto populated worlds.
In 2020, researchers at Johns Hopkins surveyed 2,561 people about their single most memorable entity encounter after inhaling DMT. Respondents reported the primary senses involved were visual and extrasensory, telepathic, and the most common labels for the entity were being, guide, spirit, alien, and helper. The team had previously run a comparable survey on ”God encounter experiences,” comparing naturally occurring encounters with those occasioned by psilocybin, LSD, ayahuasca, or DMT across five groups totaling over 4,200 people. The lead researcher put it plainly: psychedelic science is already on the fringe, and this work lives on the fringe of all science. Predictions about the future were reported by about 20% of the DMT respondents, similar to the God-encounter findings.
Thousands of people. Independently. Meeting beings who are described in overlapping ways, who deliver messages, who feel more real than real. If you are an experiencer who has met something, this is either the most threatening literature in the world or the most liberating, depending entirely on what you need to be true.
I’d argue it’s liberating, and here’s why. It demonstrates that encounter is a capacity of the human mind, a repeatable, inducible, describable capacity with consistent phenomenology across thousands of strangers. That does not tell you whether anything is on the other side. It tells you the door exists and it opens the same way for everyone. That is precisely the kind of stable, cross-cultural, cross-subject regularity that science is built to investigate. It is an invitation, not a dismissal.
Children who remember other worlds
For sixty years, the Division of Perceptual Studies at the University of Virginia School of Medicine, a real department, in a real medical school, in a real university, has been investigating young children who report memories of previous lives. They have studied over 2,500 such cases, and in many of them the child’s statements match specific details from the life of someone who died. In some cases, the children have birthmarks or birth defects congruent with wounds on the deceased person, confirmed against postmortem reports, and the apparent memories generally fade around age seven. Ian Stevenson began it; Jim Tucker directs it now and has focused on American cases.
Tucker is careful in a way I respect. He says the strength of the cases varies, that some are easily discounted, and that faulty witness memory is likely present in many, but notes there are dozens of instances where people wrote down what the children said almost from the beginning. And he says something that hits hard for anyone who’s ever tried to tell the truth about their own life and been shut down: that part of why so few cases are collected is that parents dismiss or misunderstand what their children tell them, and that if children get the message they aren’t being listened to, they stop talking.
That is the whole tragedy of our field in one sentence.
Now the counterweight, because I promised to be honest. Richard McNally’s lab at Harvard has studied people who report recovered memories of past lives and found elevated false memory propensity in that population, alongside work connecting isolated sleep paralysis to recovered memories of space alien abduction. Both things can be true. Some memories are constructed. Some cases at UVA have details that were written down before verification and match anyway. A field that can hold both of those at once is a field that is finally growing up.
The mass sighting problem
This is where people expect the mind-science argument to collapse. Fine, individual experiences are internal, but what about when a hundred people see the same thing? It’s a fair challenge, and it deserves a real answer rather than a slogan.
Phoenix, March 13, 1997. Careful investigators treat it as two unrelated events on the same night. The first, roughly 7:55 to 8:40 p.m., was a V-shaped formation described by observers as an enormous boomerang- or carpenter’s-square-shaped object, with five to ten lights holding fixed geometry, blocking background stars, silent despite slow speed. The second, later in the evening, involved a linear array of hovering lights officially attributed to parachute flares dropped by A-10 aircraft from the Maryland Air National Guard over the Barry M. Goldwater Range. The Maryland Air National Guard’s 104th Fighter Squadron later confirmed dropping LUU-2 illumination flares, and the video evidence for that second event is consistent with flares. The first event is where it stays interesting: an amateur astronomer named Mitch Stanley viewed the formation through a powerful telescope and insisted he saw individual aircraft, while FAA radar records were erased after two weeks, limiting hard data.
And then there’s the governor. Fife Symington, who in 1997 had trotted out an aide in an alien costume to mock the frenzy, reversed himself a decade later and said the lights were an alien spacecraft: “I’m a pilot and I know just about every machine that flies. It was bigger than anything that I’ve ever seen.” He described what he watched pass silently over Piestewa Peak as too symmetrical to have been flares and distinct from anything the flare explanation covers, and no state or federal agency ever formally investigated the earlier formation or took sworn statements, the only systematic canvass came from a city councilwoman acting on her own initiative.
So: one event well explained, one event never properly investigated, thousands of witnesses, and a decade-long lag before the most credentialed one told the truth about what he saw. That lag is a psychological datum. Fear of ridicule shaped the evidentiary record of a mass sighting. Mind science is already in this story, whether we noticed or not.
Ruwa, Zimbabwe, September 16, 1994. About sixty-two children at the Ariel primary school put down their jump ropes at mid-morning recess and reported seeing spacecraft and two strange beings in the grassy area beside their schoolyard. Their accounts were recorded within days by BBC journalist Tim Leach, then by researcher Cynthia Hind, and later by Harvard psychiatrist John Mack. The incident produced no recovered object, no radar record, no verified photograph, and no physical specimen. The children were asked independently to draw what they had seen, and many of the images and accounts bore striking resemblance to one another. Speaking with Mack, the children reported receiving telepathic messages carrying an environmental warning.
And the honest complication: one of the former students later claimed on camera that he made it up, a confession that could not be independently verified, and which casts a legendary encounter in an unfamiliar light. Also worth citing: Mack arrived having just published a book on UFOs and heavily invested in the topic, which is exactly the kind of interviewer effect that mind science is built to control for and that our community routinely ignores when the interviewer agrees with us.
Hessdalen, Norway, 1984–present. This is the case I wish experiencers knew better, because it is what taking a shared sighting seriously actually looks like. The phenomenon was investigated with magnetometric, radiometric and radar instrumentation beginning in 1984 by Erling Strand and his team. That 1984 report used cameras, seismographs, radar, lasers, magnetometers, Geiger counters and infrared viewers, and recorded 53 sightings during an 18-day field trip. In 1998 they installed the Blue Box, the world’s first automated anomaly detection and recording system. The lights correlate with magnetic perturbations, radio emission and radar tracks, and the phenomenon’s radiant power has been measured at up to 19 kilowatts. Residents and visitors who shared their experiences faced distrust and ridicule, and forty years later their stories remain consistent and new sightings continue.
Four decades of instruments in a valley, and the answer is still we don’t know. That’s not failure. That’s what an open question looks like when adults are handling it.
Now, where does the mind come into shared sightings? Two places, and neither is “you’re all hysterical.” First, human perception is not a camera; it’s an inference engine, and it fills gaps according to expectation. Second, we are agent-detection machines by design. Perceptual biases to over-detect the presence of other agents underlie a great deal of supernatural belief, from faces in clouds to Justin Barrett’s proposed hyperactive agency detection device. The fusiform face area responds selectively to face-like stimuli, and illusory or hallucinatory face perception arises from disturbed activity in it. The claim is that failing to detect a real agent is more costly than falsely assuming one, so we err toward seeing someone there, though I’ll note fairly that critics argue there’s no single neural module for this and that agency attribution arises from distributed systems doing broader perceptual and social work.
This is my honest read on Bigfoot, and I say it with affection for everyone in that world. A large bipedal shape in low light, in forest, in a state of heightened vigilance, in a culture with a template ready, that is the exact input condition under which a well-documented perceptual system produces a confident false positive. It is also the exact input condition under which you’d encounter a real animal. Nothing about knowing the first rules out the second. What knowing the first does is tell you what kind of evidence would settle it, and it isn’t more sightings. It never was going to be more sightings.
So what is consciousness doing in all this?
Here is the piece that changes everything, and most experiencers have never been handed it.
The dominant framework in cognitive neuroscience right now says that perception is not reception. It’s prediction. The brain is locked in a dark silent skull making constant best guesses about the causes of its sensory signals, and sensory input functions as error correction on those guesses. Anil Seth calls the result a controlled hallucination. The process is “controlled” because it is continually reined in and anchored by sensory information flowing from the world; the difference between prediction and input is prediction error, and the system’s job is to minimize it. In Seth’s framing, this hallucination is not a false perception of something that doesn’t exist, but a perception modeled by our body and constrained by the world.
Take that seriously for one minute and notice what it does to the argument we’ve all been having.
If ordinary perception is a constructed model, then every experience anyone has ever had is generated by the mind. Your kitchen. Your daughter’s face. The color red. The distinction between “real experience” and “experience your mind made” collapses, because there is no other kind. What actually varies is how tightly the model is coupled to external constraint. That is a spectrum, not a binary. Dreams sit at one end, ordinary waking perception near the other, and everything we call anomalous sits somewhere in between, in the interesting middle, where coupling is unusual.
This is why I keep saying: the mind is its own reality and cannot be discounted. Not as a spiritual affirmation. As a structural consequence of the best model neuroscience currently has. The mind is the only place any of us has ever been. It is where the kitchen is and where the light over Reelfoot Lake is. Ranking one as “real” and one as “just your mind” is a category error dressed up as skepticism.
None of this touches the hard problem: nobody can say why any of this processing is like anything from the inside. Integrated information theory, global workspace theory, analytic idealism, and a dozen other frameworks are all still on the table because none has closed the gap. Anyone who tells you consciousness is a solved problem is selling something. Which means the field where our experiences live is a field with no settled floor. That is not a reason for humility on experiencers’ part alone. It’s a reason for humility on everyone’s part.
Does parapsychology belong in this?
I think yes, carefully, and I want to show you both sides rather than tell you what to conclude.
In 2018, American Psychologist, the flagship journal of the American Psychological Association, which goes out to nearly 120,000 members, published Etzel Cardeña’s review of the experimental evidence for psi. His conclusion was that the evidence provides cumulative support for the reality of psi, and cannot be readily explained away by study quality, fraud, selective reporting, or experimental incompetence. He has since said the accumulated evidence is comparable to that of accepted phenomena in mainstream psychology and other disciplines.
And immediately, Arthur Reber and James Alcock wrote a rebuttal in the same journal arguing that parapsychological claims cannot be true. That’s how it’s supposed to work. Claim, counterclaim, in the open, at the highest level of the field.
The government version of this argument is already declassified. From the early 1970s, physicists Hal Puthoff and Russell Targ ran remote viewing research at Stanford Research Institute with CIA funding; by 1978 it was a military intelligence unit at Fort Meade. In 1995 Congress directed the CIA to evaluate the program, and the CIA hired the American Institutes for Research to review it. Statistician Jessica Utts concluded the statistical evidence was strong enough to reject the null hypothesis; something real appeared to be happening. Psychologist Ray Hyman concluded methodological flaws made the results unreliable. Both agreed that even if real, the intelligence produced was too vague to be operationally useful. The CIA accepted Hyman’s conclusion and terminated the program. Utts’s own report is in the CIA’s reading room, stating that her aim was to determine whether psychic functioning had been scientifically established.
You can read all of it yourself. That’s the point. Twenty-three years of government research on the reach of the human mind, with a formal split verdict from two named scientists, sitting in a public archive, and hardly anyone in our community has actually opened it.
What I take from parapsychology is not “psi is proven.” It’s that a serious, methodologically disciplined community has been asking whether mind extends past the skull, has produced results contested at the highest levels of psychology, and has done it with pre-registration, blinding, and meta-analysis, while our community has largely been doing it with anecdote and vibes. If the answer turns out to be no, I want to have earned that no.
What are we actually afraid of?
I’ve been asking myself this for years, and I’ve been asking other experiencers. Here is what I’ve found, and I’m going to be unkind to myself first.
We’re afraid it means we’re crazy. This is the big one and it isn’t paranoia; the frame really was pathologizing. It took until 1994 for the DSM-IV to add V62.89, “Religious or Spiritual Problem,” a category for when the focus of clinical attention is a religious or spiritual problem, including distressing experiences involving loss or questioning of faith or of other spiritual values not necessarily tied to an organized religion. The push came from transpersonal clinicians and the Spiritual Emergence Network, out of concern about the mental health system pathologizing spiritual experience. And here’s the sting: since its inclusion, clinicians largely have not used the code or received adequate training in religious and spiritual competency. The door was built. Almost nobody walks through it. Remember Luhrmann’s observation that in the U.S., diagnostic categories for psychotic disorders carry a quality of the diagnosis of death. Of course we’re afraid. We’ve watched what happens.
We’re afraid that “it came from my mind” means “it didn’t happen.” It doesn’t, and there’s hard data. McNally and Clancy at Harvard measured heart rate, skin conductance, and facial EMG in people who reported alien abduction while they listened to scripts of their own experiences. The experiencers showed physiological reactions as great or greater than people who cannot shake memories of combat and sexual abuse. Their responses were comparable to PTSD patients hearing scripts of their actual traumas. McNally does not believe anyone was abducted. His own data show their bodies responded exactly as if something happened to them. The wound is real regardless of the origin of the blade. Any framework that can’t hold that isn’t worth adopting.
We’re afraid of what we’ll find if we look inward. This is mine, personally, and it’s the one I’d identify as the deepest. Because there is a finding sitting in this literature that goes straight through people like me. Kenneth Ring’s Omega Project studied NDErs and UFO experiencers together and reported that one significant predisposing factor in the developmental history of extraordinary experiencers may be relatively high levels of childhood abuse and trauma, and that individuals reporting UFO encounters and NDErs appear more likely to show dissociative tendencies. From that he proposed an “encounter-prone personality”, a spiritually sensitive, ecologically oriented type, though I’ll note his critics found the reasoning circular and the conclusions inflated.
I know exactly how that finding feels when you’re the one it describes. It feels like the last theft. Like they’ve come to take the one thing that was mine, the thing that happened to me and not to the people who hurt me and file it under damage. That’s why we flinch.
But look at what it actually says. It says children who were forced to develop an extraordinary capacity to leave our bodies, to go somewhere else, and to survive by going somewhere else, grew up with an unusual relationship to the boundary between worlds. That is not a diagnosis. That’s a skill acquired under fire. Nobody in the field is asking the obvious next question, which is what such a capacity is like when it’s no longer being used for survival. What it is when it’s turned on purposely, by an adult, in safety, and with attention.
Nobody has studied us as practitioners.
We’re afraid of losing the community. Say out loud in most experiencer spaces that you’re exploring psychological explanations and watch how fast you become suspect, get demonized and shunned. We police each other into a single permitted interpretation and then wonder why no serious scientist wants to come near us. We have built a room where only one answer is allowed and then complained that nobody visits.
We’re afraid of ontological shock, and we’re right to be. John Mack understood that the real damage of contact isn’t the encounter; it’s the collapse of the world you had. Turning that inward is worse, because if the mind can make a world that convincing, then everything you’re standing on right now, every certainty, every memory, and every ordinary Tuesday, is made of the same material. That is genuinely frightening. It is also a doorway, and I’m willing to walk through it.
The missing people
Which brings me to the question I really wanted to ask: does the absence of reasonable, objective mind scientists in the anomalous community hold us back?
Yes. Catastrophically. And it’s a two-way failure.
Our side treats psychological explanation as an insult, so we drive away anyone who offers one, so the only researchers who will talk to us are those who already agree with us, so our evidence base is contaminated by interviewer effects that we then cite as confirmation. Their side treats our reports as symptoms, so they never collect the phenomenology carefully enough to find the structure in it, so they generate models that don’t fit what we actually report, so we dismiss them, and the loop tightens.
But there are people doing it right, and we should know their names. The Division of Perceptual Studies at UVA, with sixty years of case files. Etzel Cardeña’s CERCAP at Lund, researching anomalous experiences, the neurophenomenology of hypnotic phenomena, hypnotizability and dissociation. Baland Jalal, doing genuinely cross-cultural work on the shadow at the foot of the bed. Adam Zeman, who found an entire population by taking one man’s strange report seriously.
And in the humanities, Jeffrey Kripal at Rice, whose whole project is arguing that the study of religion has always taken anomalous experience seriously as the originating core of religions, and that the sciences and humanities need to talk. He organized the Archives of the Impossible symposium at Rice, an actual university archive for exactly the material our community keeps in shoeboxes. His argument is that we have to “decolonize reality itself” if we’re going to take human diversity seriously.
Then there’s Garry Nolan at Stanford, and I include him with a caution I’d want applied to anything I said. In 2013 he was brought MRI scans of personnel with health complaints after proximity to suspected anomalous craft, and those scans highlighted anomalies in the caudate and putamen. His account is that these people were not damaged but showed an over-connection of neurons between the head of the caudate and the putamen. That work led him to collaborate with Harvard scientists on the role of those regions in intelligence and intuition. This has not been through the peer-reviewed gauntlet the way the other work in this essay has, and it needs to be. But his framing of the epistemology is the most generous thing a working scientist has said about us in years: that a firsthand experience is at one level an anecdote and at another an undeniable fact for the person who had it, that they don’t need anybody else to tell them what they saw, but they might need help interpreting what it meant and why it happened to them.
That’s the deal. That’s the whole deal. You don’t need permission for the fact. You need company for the meaning.
What this would give us
Here’s the part I actually care about, the reason I’ve spent weeks on writing this article.
If we developed real fluency in the mind sciences, if experiencers became the most psychologically literate community in the world instead of the least, three things would change.
- We’d get better data on the phenomenon itself. Right now, every anomalous report is a mixed signal: some external event, some perceptual construction, some cultural template, and some memory reconstruction, all fused. We treat that fusion as noise or we deny it exists. But you cannot isolate a signal you refuse to model. The path to knowing whether something is out there runs through rigorous understanding of what’s in here. There is no way around. There is only through.
- We’d get a real approach to non-human intelligence. Think about the DMT data. Thousands of people meeting beings with consistent characteristics, delivering messages, in a state induced by a molecule. Think about lucid dream figures that refuse the dreamer’s instructions. Think about voices that are cruel in California and playful in Chennai. In every one of those cases, a human mind is interacting with something that presents as an agent and does not behave as though it’s under the mind’s control. We do not currently possess a way to tell an internally generated intelligence from an externally encountered one from the inside. That is not a small gap. That is the gap. And if we ever do meet something genuinely non-human, out there, or in a machine, or in the water, or in a category we haven’t got a word for, the instrument that will have to make the discrimination is a trained human mind. We haven’t built the instrument. We’ve just been arguing about the readings.
- We’d stop losing our own people. This one is not abstract. Every week someone in one of my spaces is deciding between two impossible options: believe the literal external interpretation and lose their credibility, family, and sometimes their grip; or accept the dismissal and lose the truth of what happened to them. Mind science offers a third door. Your experience was real. Your body proved it. The mind that produced it is the strangest object in the known universe. You are not lying and you are not broken and you don’t have to pick.
Reelfoot
I still don’t know what I saw over that lake.
Forty-odd years on, and the honest inventory looks like this. I know something in the sky did not match my model of the sky. I know what it did to my physical body. I know it happened in a time when something as large as a football field or bigger wasn’t common at all.
I know that thousands of people over Arizona saw geometry hold formation and blot out stars, and that no agency ever properly investigated it. I know a valley in Norway has been instrumented for forty years and still hands back unknown. I know that a brain with no oxygen can produce the electrical signature of a mind for an hour, that a dreamer can do arithmetic from inside a world made of memory, that certainty has an address in the insula, that a shadow at the foot of the bed is a jinn in Cairo and a witch-cat in Italy and the same shadow in both places.
I know I left my body as a child because leaving was the only exit available, and I know some researcher would put that in a column labeled dissociation, and I know he wouldn’t be entirely wrong, and I also know he wouldn’t be within a hundred miles of the whole of it.
What I’ve stopped needing is the verdict. What I want now is the map. Not because the map explains me away, I’ve read enough of it now to know it doesn’t, that at every edge the map goes blank and says here we do not know, but because the map is the only thing that turns an experience into knowledge. Everything else turns it into a story we tell each other.
The mind is not the small explanation. The mind is the biggest thing we’ve ever found. It builds a world every night, holds worlds no one else can enter, generates certainty and terror and light on its own recognizance, and quite possibly reaches past the skull in ways two named scientists in a CIA-commissioned report could not agree about. We were handed the strangest instrument in the universe and told it was a liability. It was never a liability.
It’s the only ship any of us has ever had. And nobody has taught us how to sail it.
I write to live. It’s all I can do now; create a living archive of my explorations as an experiencer, and continue to write in order to remain intact inside my own sanity.

Centarficus © 2015 by Vennie Kocsis is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. All recommendations are my own.
Support Vennie’s writing with a one-time contribution or establish a monthly donation.
Share this post:
Discover more from Vennie Kocsis
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


You must be logged in to post a comment.