The Bow and the Book

Inside the International Order of the Rainbow for Girls, its origins, its ceremonies, its guarded texts, and the women who walked away.

McAlester, 1922

The room was a Scottish Rite auditorium in a coal town in eastern Oklahoma, and on the evening of April 6, 1922, one hundred and seventy-one girls were made members of something that did not exist a few months earlier.

The ceremony was performed by the women of South McAlester Chapter No. 149, Order of the Eastern Star, mothers, aunts, and neighbors, under the direction of a Christian minister and 33° Freemason named Reverend W. Mark Sexson. He had been invited to give an address to the chapter. Instead of a speech, he left them an institution. He had been studying the Order of DeMolay1, the Masonic order for boys founded in Kansas City three years earlier, and he suggested the girls deserved the same.

The archives disagree on the size of that first class, the Order’s own history and its New York jurisdiction say 171 girls; the National Register of Historic Places nomination for its headquarters says the installation class numbered 86. Either way, it spread like weather. Assemblies were chartered in Arkansas, Texas, Mississippi, and Washington before the end of that first year. New York followed in 1924. By 1940 there were roughly 50,000 members. Today the Order claims that more than a million girls have been initiated since 1922.

Consider what year this was. The Nineteenth Amendment was two years old. A generation of American women had just been handed the right to vote and had no civic apparatus to practice it in. Freemasonry was in its American heyday, and it was busy building a family: the lodge for the father, the Eastern Star for the mother, DeMolay for the son, Rainbow and Job’s Daughters for the daughter. Sexson’s innovation was not the ritual. It was noticing that the daughters were unaccounted for.

The Bow of Promise

The symbol is Genesis 9, the rainbow God sets in the clouds after the flood, the sign of a covenant not to destroy the earth again. Sexson took that image of a promise made visible and built a curriculum out of its colors.

Seven stations, seven colors, and seven lessons:

  • Red: Love
  • Orange: Religion
  • Yellow: Nature
  • Green: Immortality
  • Blue: Fidelity
  • Indigo: Patriotism
  • Violet: Service

Three more virtues sit above them as elected offices, Faith, Hope, and Charity, for ten lessons in total. Presiding over all of it is the Worthy Advisor, a teenage girl who functions as president, with a Worthy Associate Advisor beneath her, a Drill Leader who commands the floor work, a Chaplain, a Recorder, a Treasurer, a Musician and Choir Director, and two guards: the Confidential Observer at the inner door, and the Outer Observer at the outer one.

The Order’s emblem is a red, white, and blue rainbow carrying four gold letters, B.F.C.L., over two clasped hands.

Colorful rainbow graphic with BFCT letters, a central white triangle containing the letter R, and two hands clasping beneath it

The letters stand for Bible, Flag, Constitution, and Lambskin apron, the last a direct borrowing from the aprons of Freemasonry. Those four items are also the contents of the Pot of Gold, the vessel that sits in the assembly room covered until the moment the ritual calls for it to be opened.

Book page showing a floor plan for a Kingdom Hall and its seating arrangement, including labeled areas for attendants, elders, service, prayer, literature, and observers.

Everything about the design is a small girl-sized replica of a lodge. That is either its charm or its problem, depending on who you ask.

What a Meeting Looks Like

Assemblies meet roughly twice a month, usually in a Masonic temple. Officers serve terms of four or six months, and there is an unwritten escalator, Faith to Charity to Hope to Worthy Associate Advisor to Worthy Advisor, that carries a girl up the line if she keeps showing up and keeps memorizing.

And there is a great deal to memorize. The opening and closing are delivered from the printed Ritual; every station has a lecture the officer must recite from memory, word-perfect. The dress code specifies floor-length or tea-length formals for ceremonial meetings. Business is conducted under Robert’s Rules of Order, which means that a fourteen-year-old learns to move, second, and call the question, before she can even drive.

A woman who joined a Rhode Island assembly at thirteen left a description of the room that has the texture of a dream: royal blue carpet, carved thrones on a raised platform, an organ, a domed ceiling painted with sky and clouds, and at the center a white-draped altar with an open Bible on it, and seven chairs arranged in a semicircle before it, each with a small gold table beside it. The girls came entered with Pomp and Circumstance, dressed in white gowns, two lines crossing and recrossing in figures that must have looked like choreography from the galleries above, and each one ending precisely in front of her own chair.

She was the star candidate that night. She wore her aunt’s size-two wedding dress.

The Initiation

The candidate is led around the room by the sister of Faith. She is stopped before each throne, and at each stop a girl recites a long-memorized passage at her. She is brought before the seven colors, and one by one they explain what their color means, and one by one she carries a satin sash from each station to the altar and hooks it to a ring, until a rainbow radiates from the center of the room.

Beneath the pageantry is a sequence of promises. According to a former Worthy Advisor who later published what she could reconstruct, the ceremony contains an obligation taken kneeling at the altar, three pledges, and seven vows, and by her count she had taken sixteen oaths, vows, obligations, and pledges by the end of her time in the Order. The candidate walks the perimeter of the room fourteen times over the course of the ritual. The obligation itself binds her to obedience to God and country, to her father and mother, to the statutes of the Supreme Assembly, and to never unlawfully reveal the secrets of the Order.

Then she is given the parts you cannot find in the printed book: a word whispered in her ear, a password for the outer door, a grip in which the fingers slide to form a bow, a sign of the rainbow traced from shoulder to shoulder, a sign of secrecy made with two fingers at the lips, and a sign of distress. If she cannot make the sign of distress, there are words she can say instead, and any Rainbow Girl who hears them is bound to answer and come.

There is also a catechism used to test a visiting member from another assembly, and it is the most beautiful thing in the whole apparatus. Asked whether she is a member, she does not answer yes. She answers that she has seen the bow in the clouds and gone looking for its treasure. Asked whether she found it, she says she found only part of it.

The Books

A tiered system of texts exists, some published, some restricted, and one that is deliberately never printed at all.

The Ritual. The printed book containing the opening, closing, initiation, installation, and the station lectures. Officers learn their parts from it. It has been commercially reprinted and turns up on Amazon and in estate sales; the Scottish Rite Masonic Museum & Library collects it as material culture.

The Secret Work. This is the one that matters. According to the former Worthy Advisor cited above, the obligation taken at the altar is not written in the Ritual. It exists in a separate document kept by the Mother Advisor at all times. To learn it, a Worthy Advisor or Worthy Advisor–elect must arrange to meet the Mother Advisor at her home or at the Masonic temple and take it from her mouth to her ear. The remaining secret work, the word, the grip, the signs, and the test catechism, is delivered after the Pot of Gold lecture.

Sit with the mechanics of that. The single most binding text in a teenage girl’s membership is the one text she is never handed. It is transmitted orally, in private, by an adult woman, in a house or a temple, and it cannot be taken home, photographed, shown to a parent, or read twice for a second opinion.

The Gold Book and the jurisdictional handbooks are governance, floor work, customs, and the mechanics of advisory boards. There are semi-public; grand jurisdictions post versions of them.

The roll books and record books keep the attendance, merit points, and awards. Ordinary paperwork with an unusual amount of authority attached: attendance is verified through the roll book, and merit bars and the Pot of Gold award are earned on a point system.

The final irony is that the secrecy no longer holds. The Rainbow ritual and its secret work have been transcribed and posted online for years, by Dutch archivists at Stichting Argus, who host Masonic and para-Masonic rituals as a documentation project, and by American counter-cult researchers who post them as evidence. Anyone can read tonight what a girl in 1962 was told she must never say aloud. What survives is not really the secret, more than the experience of having been made to swear to it.

Who Actually Holds the Bow

On paper, Rainbow is a youth-led organization, and in the day-to-day that is largely true: the girls plan the events, run the meetings, choose the service projects, and raise the money.

The scaffolding above them is adult and it is Masonic. Each assembly answers to an advisory board of seven to fifteen adults, Master Masons, Eastern Star and Amaranth members, majority members, and parents, with a Mother Advisor as the liaison. Above that sit District Deputies, then Supreme Deputies and Supreme Inspectors appointed by their predecessors. At the summit is the House of Gold: fifty seats, and the appointments are for life.

Fifty adults hold lifetime seats over an organization whose members age out at twenty and whose officers turn over every six months. That asymmetry is not a scandal. It is simply the shape of the structural thing, and it is worth identifying plainly, because most of the girls inside of it are too young to have a vocabulary for that intricate level of power.

Membership rules encode their own era. A candidate must believe in a Supreme Being, have parental permission, and, per the Order’s stated guidelines, must not be married or previously married, must not be living with a partner, must not have children, and must not be pregnant. Majority arrives at twenty, or earlier by marriage. The plain reading is that the sexual conduct of teenage girls is a membership condition, and it always has been. A girl can be a good candidate on Tuesday and ineligible on Wednesday for reasons that have nothing to do with love, service, or patriotism, her fate left to ordinary teenager behavior chalked up to scandal.

The Ones Who Left

Lora Burton joined at eleven because a friend described the fun and refused to answer her questions about the rest. Six weeks later she was initiated. She was elected to the station of Faith at thirteen, installed as Worthy Advisor of her Iowa assembly at fifteen, and made a Grand Representative the following summer. Over nine years she held nearly every office her assembly had. She was told that her name was on the list for the Grand Cross of Color.

At eighteen she became an evangelical Christian, and the two frameworks began to grind against each other. She has written that the rituals had seemed so beautiful she could not initially see any conflict at all, that she had memorized the lectures and delivered them back without ever examining what they really said. When she asked her Mother Advisor direct questions, she was met with vague half-answers.

She applied for a demit, a discharge. Her assembly did not grant it. Twenty-two months passed. During that time she was pressured to hold her Majority Service, the graduation ceremony that moves a girl out of Rainbow and, ideally, into the Eastern Star. She was nearly twenty-two when a letter finally arrived with her Majority Card inside.

She then did the thing the obligation forbids. In 1989 she founded Rooftop Ministries, the name an acronym, and also a reference to Matthew 10:27, what is whispered in your ear, proclaim from the rooftops, and published her reconstruction of the Rainbow Secret Work, along with an admission that her memory was imperfect and the text incomplete.

Her critique is theological, and it should be read as such: she left because she came to believe Freemasonry and Christianity are incompatible with each other, not because anyone harmed her. She is careful to be clear about that. But the procedural detail in her account is the part that unravels it a bit; a girl asked to leave, and it took nearly two years, and the pressure to complete the ceremony continued the whole time the organization knew it would expel her.

Institutional defection has happened too. On a parenting forum in 2009, a former Grand officer described roughly half the assemblies in her state seceding from the Supreme Assembly after a governance fight, taking their adult leadership with them and forming an independent group, the International Service Organization for Young Women. She said the girls’ officers had received emails from Supreme insisting it was a business organization first and a girls’ organization second. This account is a single recollection on a message board rather than a documented history, and it deserves that caveat, but splits of exactly this kind are common in the fraternal world, and the woman telling it also said Rainbow was one of the best things she ever did.

That doubled feeling is the most consistent thing in every ex-member account I found. Almost nobody says it was all bad. They say it was beautiful, and it taught them to speak in public, but something about it does not sit right years later.

Now

Rainbow has been shrinking since the 1970s, along with nearly every fraternal and civic order in the United States. California, once a stronghold, is down to roughly 53 assemblies. Jurisdictional websites cite membership around 20,000 worldwide. Headquarters is still the International Temple in McAlester, built in 1950–51 and listed on the National Register in 2013. Delaware, Minnesota, Utah, and Wyoming have no assemblies at all.

The Order has modernized where it can. Membership no longer requires a Masonic relative. Its literature states plainly that girls of all races and religions are welcome, and that it is not a religion, a cult, or a secret order. There is an online leadership program, a social media presence, and a service project chosen each year by the Grand Worthy Advisor. Its alumnae include Sandra Day O’Connor, Senator Olympia Snowe, and NASA astronaut Dorothy Metcalf-Lindenburger.

And the Secret Work is still not printed. A girl in 2026 who becomes Worthy Advisor still goes to her Mother Advisor’s house to learn, by ear, the words she will use to bind the next eleven-year-old at the altar.

That is the whole thing in a sentence. A hundred years of teaching girls to stand up straight, speak from memory, run a meeting, and feed a community, and one text that is only ever passed mouth to ear, from a woman to a child, in a room with the door closed.

The Case Against It

There is no scandal here in the sense the word usually carries. I found no criminal prosecution, no civil suit, no embezzlement, and no cover-up attached to the International Order of the Rainbow for Girls. Anyone who goes looking for one should know in advance that the search itself is treacherous: Rainbow is a common name, and the two ugliest results that surface immediately: a Georgia youth shelter where an employee was charged with molestation and three colleagues with concealing it, and a California LGBTQ+ nonprofit whose director was arrested in a police sting, have nothing whatever to do with this organization. They should be kept well away from any account of it.

What exists instead is criticism of a structural and theological kind, and it is substantial.

The churches. The most authoritative document identifying Rainbow directly is a 1985 report by William Whalen prepared for the U.S. bishops’ Committee for Pastoral Research and Practices. It treats Masonic affiliation as a pastoral problem, identifies the two central objections as religious naturalism and the swearing of oaths, and then lists the youth orders, DeMolay, Job’s Daughters, and Rainbow Girls, as adjacent cases. Its finding about them is that the young people involved do not swear Masonic oaths and are not considered Masons, and so the strict rule need not extend to them, though pastors should not encourage the affiliation either.

That finding is the most interesting sentence in the whole literature, because the ritual contradicts it. The Secret Work contains an obligation taken kneeling at the altar; a former Worthy Advisor counted more than a dozen oaths, vows, obligations and pledges across her nine years. Either the committee assessed the order without reading its ritual, or it drew a distinction between a Masonic oath and an oath administered by a Masonic auxiliary that would be invisible to the girl kneeling. The same report is unsparing about the parent institution on another front, stating that the predominant Blue Lodges refused to initiate anyone known to be Black, with one recognized exception in Newark, and calling on American Masonry to bring itself into line with the rest of society. That was published in 1985.

The objection is not a Catholic peculiarity. The report catalogues Eastern Orthodoxy, several Lutheran bodies, the Christian Reformed Church, most Pentecostals, the Nazarenes, Seventh-day Adventists, Quakers, Mennonites, Free Methodists, the Assemblies of God and the Salvation Army as opposing lodge affiliation. Rainbow’s most persistent named critics are evangelical counter-cult ministries, and their argument is the one Burton made: that a child cannot meaningfully consent to a system of oaths whose contents she is shown only after she has agreed to be bound by them.

The screening. The sharpest institutional criticism is also the least discussed. In 2006 the Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of Texas issued an edict concerning the Masonic youth groups, reproduced since on a Masonic forum. It recounts that the Texas trustees had spent three years asking all three orders to run background checks on adult advisors and to train them in child protection awareness. DeMolay already had both. Rainbow did not but designed and implemented them after the Grand Lodge asked. Job’s Daughters International did not, which is what forced the edict.

Rainbow is the middle case in that story and comes out of it reasonably well, asked, and complied. But read it from the other end: as recently as the early 2000s, in one of the largest jurisdictions in the country, adults supervising eleven-year-olds inside closed temple rooms were not being screened, and it took a Grand Lodge three years of asking to change that. Whatever happened in the eight decades before, there is no mechanism that would have recorded it.

The exits. Burton’s demit took twenty-two months, during which she was pressured to complete a ceremony she had asked to be released from. One case is not a pattern. But a membership a girl can enter in six weeks and cannot leave in under a year, and a half is worth noticing, and no jurisdiction publishes data on how long discharges take.

The reassurances. California’s jurisdiction tells prospective families that no actions will ever be required of members that would go against their personal beliefs or the beliefs of their church, and that members are never asked to make pledges contrary to their moral values. That is offered in good faith, and for the ordinary business of an assembly it is plainly true. It sits awkwardly against an obligation that is never printed, cannot be read in advance, and is learned privately from an adult.

The rules and the name. A girl is ineligible if she is married, previously married, living with a partner, pregnant, or a mother, conditions applied to no one else in the Masonic family. And the Indiana jurisdiction’s FAQ now has to answer a question Sexson never anticipated, stating that the order is not associated with the LGBTQIA+ community but is inclusive regardless of sexual orientation, and that the 1922 name refers to God’s covenant. Whether the answer satisfies anyone is contested, but the fact that it must be given at all is a measure of how far the symbol has drifted from the people who first claimed it.

The shape. Fifty adults hold lifetime seats in the House of Gold. The girls hold six-month terms. That is not misconduct. It is a design, and it is the reason every criticism above is structural rather than criminal: the asymmetry is built in, and it operates whether or not anyone abuses it.

The Church’s objection to Rainbow was never that a child was bound before she could understand, its own founding sacrament does exactly that, permanently and by design. The objection was to oaths. Which means the two institutions disagree about the form of childhood binding, not the fact of it, and the only meaningful difference between them is whether the child can afterward tell anyone what she agreed to.

The Bow and the Book

A rainbow is a promise you can see. That was the whole of Sexson’s idea in 1922: take the covenant God hung in the clouds after the flood, hand it to girls who had just watched their mothers win the vote and had nowhere to practice citizenship, and let them learn on it, how to stand, how to speak from memory, how to run a room, and how to give away money they raised themselves. A hundred years and a million initiations later, that part still works. Nearly every woman who left the order says so, including the ones who left angry.

But the promise came with a book, and the book was never handed over. It is still carried by an adult, still taught in a kitchen or a locked temple, still spoken once into a girl’s ear and never written where her parents can read it. The bishops who reviewed the order concluded there were no oaths. The girls who took them counted more than a dozen. Both of those things have been true at the same time for a century, and they can only be true at the same time because the text sits where nobody outside the room can check it.

That is what makes this worth writing about, and it is not an accusation of Rainbow as a scandal; it is an argument about consent, conducted at the scale of a thousand small rooms. What the Order teaches a girl is to be visible, to stand up straight, to look out at the assembly, and to say the words with her whole chest. What it asks of her first is to promise, sight unseen, to keep something in the dark. She carries both out of that room and carries them for the rest of their lives.

And what does it cost the spirit to keep an oath that requires a lifetime dedication to secrecy?

Article References

Organizational and historical

Ritual texts and the “secret work”

First-person accounts

Criticism and institutional response

Further reading

For the ones who grew up inside ritualistic environments:

Cult & High Control Group Recovery Reads – for understanding the structural dynamics of high-control organizations and the long work of recovering a sense of self that belongs entirely to you.

Cult Child Companion Books – for the ones whose childhood was shaped by systems of secrecy, oath-taking, and adult authority that operated beyond their ability to question or consent.

Shadow Work & Healing Books – for doing the interior work of separating what you agreed to before you were old enough to understand what you were agreeing to — from who you actually are.

Handwritten black signature reading “Vernice” with a small butterfly graphic on a green background
  1. Order of DeMolay. Founded in Kansas City, Missouri, in March 1919 by Frank S. Land, a Freemason and Scottish Rite relief administrator who was asked to find work for Louis Lower, the sixteen-year-old son of a recently deceased lodge brother. Land met Lower and eight of his friends at the Scottish Rite Temple in February to discuss forming a club and told them the story of Jacques de Molay while they were casting about for a name. The last Grand Master of the Knights Templar, de Molay was burned at the stake in Paris in 1314 after retracting a confession extracted under torture, martyred, in the order’s telling, for refusing to betray his brethren, which made fidelity under interrogation the moral center of the whole enterprise. A ritual was written that summer with the help of a Kansas City drama critic, and the first class received the degree and obligation on September 27, 1919. Chapters are sponsored by Masonic bodies, led by an elected Master Councilor and overseen by an adult Advisory Council; membership is open to young men aged twelve to twenty-one who acknowledge a higher spiritual power, and active membership now runs around 12,000 worldwide. It was the template Sexson was working from when he stood up in McAlester three years later. ↩︎

Centarficus © 2015 by Vennie Kocsis is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. All recommendations are my own.

Support Vennie’s writing with a one-time contribution or establish a monthly donation.

Share this post:


Discover more from Vennie Kocsis

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.